The Elite and "Populism"
The Elite and "Populism"
By Ming-Ching Luo
People have an instinct to interpret their own circumstances in ways that let them live happily. And to tie one's own work or profession to "justice" is a maneuver at which the well-read—so skilled at "interpretation"—are especially practiced. This instinct, combined with an environment in which controlled access to education kept the educated few, has lent "intellectuals" and "scholars" an extra halo in society. It is as though, once a person dons the title of "scholar" or "doctor," people—awed by the radiance of knowledge—will hear him out attentively however much his pronouncements defy "common sense," and will take those pronouncements to be uttered in the name of "justice."
In the marketplace of opinion of late, one often hears many a "loyal minister cast out from court" denouncing the sin of "populism," and even talk of "national ruin" has appeared. Such views hold, broadly, that in a vulgar democratic politics the majority of voters, being of low intellectual attainment, are easily bewitched and cannot make rational judgments, so that the quality of policy declines. Meanwhile the views of the enlightened few go unheeded by the masses, no longer able to exert the influence they once commanded with a single call.
But are voters really more benighted than before? If receiving an education is an effective route to acquiring basic powers of logical reasoning, then over the past dozen-odd years—even as "elites" have ceaselessly questioned whether there are "too many university students"—the number of university students has nonetheless grown several times over, and the nation's access to education is plainly far better than in previous generations. How could voters possibly be more ignorant than before? On the other hand, in recent years the government can no longer control the flow of information, and people's opportunities to obtain it have markedly increased. Might it be, then, that the problem of public ignorance that so worries the "elite" actually stems from the elite's own insufficient understanding of present-day society?
Democratic politics is of course imperfect; it merely reflects the average condition of the society. But the voting rule of one person, one vote, each vote of equal weight, is an institution that human society has slowly evolved to resolve conflicts of interest with relatively little strife—a minimum requirement that every participant in the system must accept. When the collective decision does not accord with one's own opinion, an individual may still use his protected right of speech to strive to influence others' choices. But there is really no need—and no right—to belittle the weight of others' choices on that account. Everyone must understand that however much one fancies oneself an "elite," one in fact holds but a single vote. To account for one's predicament, when one's own opinion is not on the majority side, by accusing the many of "populism" may be nothing more than a way of masking one's own inability to persuade others and to sell the "truth" one believes in.
Second, Taiwanese society is changing quite rapidly. However much one may once have been regarded as an "elite," once had one's wisdom worshipped and admired by all, when one's way of seeing the world no longer fits with others', it is not necessarily the world that has gone wrong—far more likely, it merely reflects one's own stagnation. Faced with this, the better attitude is first to understand, with humility, how the world has changed. Otherwise one may well find oneself declaiming with passion while the listeners grow ever fewer and one's influence ever smaller. At that point the crux of the matter may truly be not that the many are growing more ignorant, but that one has simply failed to grasp the rapid change in the world and is marking time in place—tripped up, instead, by one's own preconceptions.
Reprinted with the author's permission from "The Ideology Café" (March 30, 2004).
